The largest UK based online retailer of musical instruments and music equipment
5-Jan-2018 – 770p – £160.7m – PER 59.3
Trading Update For The 4 Months September 2017 To December 2017 – Revenues up 42% to £34.564m, reflecting same (42%) increase in own brand and other brand. Trading is “in line with the board’s expectations”. The group is confident it “will continue to grow rapidly over the medium and longer term, as we continue our mission to become the best musical instrument and equipment retailer in Europe”.
This is impressive growth indeed but I have my reservations. The Operating Margin is very small (2.67%), the ROCE is not particularly impressive (7.97%) and the PER is 59.3. Comparing 2018 forecasts and 2019 forecasts, Revenue £81.3 vs £102.1 (+25%), Profit £2.14m vs £2.8m (+30%). On a PER of 59.3 they’re going to have to surprise on the upside here.
Subsequent Note – And the products I looked at were 10%+ cheaper on Amazon.
2-Mar-2018 – 642p – £134.0m – PER 49.6
Trading Update For The 12 Months To End February 2018 – Wow, that’s a speedy update, not expecting bad news in this one! And, Revenue is up 43% from £80.1m, website conversion is up from 2.75% to 3.25%, active customers up 39% and own brand sales are keeping pace with other brand sales. But, I think this a fly in the ointment – “EBITDA for the second half of FY18 will be ahead of the six-month period ended 28 February 2017, although as a result of the investments we have made during the year into our customer proposition, infrastructure, staff, systems and marketing, we expect EBITDA for the full financial year ended 28 February 2018 to be in line with our FY17 result”.
I still have reservations here and will remain Neutral for now. Although I am coming round to the view that if that’s the end of the spending then Margin and Profit here could go gangbusters!
15-May-2018 – 726p – £146.9m – PER 61.0
Preliminary Unaudited Results For The 12 Months To End February 2018 – Revenue up 43% to £80.1m, PBT down -43% to £1,5m. Active customers up 39% and conversion increased from 2.75% to 3.25%. 2019 trading so far is in-line, expecting to meet expectations.
I am going to remain Neutral here, still not entirely convinced on a PER of 61.
27-Jul-2018 – 658p – £137.8m – PER 50.5
AGM Trading Update – Distribution centre relocation and upgrade on-track – Confident of meeting FY expectations (as Revenue growth is strong in a highly competitive market (strange to mention this, they know it already and so do we)).
Having dropped from a PER of 60+ I am pondering whether this is looking more attractive now. I think it is and if this update was more upbeat it would have made it even more so – I will remain Neutral and keep an eye out for that Trading Update in September.